1958 Cleveland Indians

Franchise seasons · 1950s seasons

Independent, unofficial historical lineup simulator. Games here are simulated exhibitions, not historical results.

Roster and season statistics

Only players appear here. Staff are excluded from lineup choices. — means the source has no usable value. A roster player may have no batting or pitching row if they did not appear in those tables.

Player	Position group	No.	Stat rows	AB	H	HR	AVG	IP	ERA	Rating
Gary Bell	Pitchers	39	pitching	—	—	—	—	182.00	3.31	Average (55) — 23 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 3.31 over 182.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dick Brodowski	Pitchers	48	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	0.00	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Chuck Churn	Pitchers	32	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	6.23	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Jim Constable	Pitchers	37	pitching	—	—	—	—	9.33	11.57	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Don Ferrarese	Pitchers	34	pitching	—	—	—	—	94.67	3.71	Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 3.71 over 94.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Mike Garcia	Pitchers	25	No stat row	—	—	—	—	—	—	No rating The source has no pitching stat row for this player. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Mudcat Grant	Pitchers	33	pitching	—	—	—	—	204.00	3.84	Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 3.84 over 204.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Bob Kelly	Pitchers	37	pitching	—	—	—	—	27.67	5.20	Average (48) — 92 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 5.20 over 27.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Bob Lemon	Pitchers	21	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	5.33	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Morrie Martin	Pitchers	32	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	2.41	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Cal McLish	Pitchers	22	pitching	—	—	—	—	225.67	2.99	Average (58) — 10 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 2.99 over 225.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Don Mossi	Pitchers	12	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	3.90	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Ray Narleski	Pitchers	20	pitching	—	—	—	—	183.33	4.07	Average (50) — 76 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 4.07 over 183.33 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Steve Ridzik	Pitchers	35	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	2.08	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Herb Score	Pitchers	27	pitching	—	—	—	—	41.00	3.95	Average (51) — 62 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 3.95 over 41.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dick Tomanek	Pitchers	29	pitching	—	—	—	—	57.67	5.62	Below average (44) — 123 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 5.62 over 57.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Hoyt Wilhelm	Pitchers	26	pitching	—	—	—	—	—	2.49	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Hal Woodeshick	Pitchers	28	pitching	—	—	—	—	71.67	3.64	Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rosters An earned-run average of 3.64 over 71.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dick Brown	Catchers	11	batting	173	41	7	.237	—	—	Average (49) — 137 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 173 at-bats and 7 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Russ Nixon	Catchers	15	batting	376	113	9	.301	—	—	Average (57) — 34 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 376 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Jay Porter	Catchers	4	batting	85	17	4	.200	—	—	Average (47) — 175 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 85 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Earl Averill, Jr.	Infielders	2	No stat row	—	—	—	—	—	—	No rating The source has no batting stat row for this player. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Bobby Ávila	Infielders	1	batting	375	95	5	.253	—	—	Average (49) — 137 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 375 at-bats and 5 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Chico Carrasquel	Infielders	17	batting	156	40	9	.225	—	—	Average (52) — 78 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 156 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Billy Harrell	Infielders	38	batting	229	50	7	.218	—	—	Average (46) — 191 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 229 at-bats and 7 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Fred Hatfield	Infielders	7	batting	8	1	0	.125	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Billy Hunter	Infielders	7	batting	190	37	0	.195	—	—	Below average (41) — 239 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 190 at-bats and 0 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Randy Jackson	Infielders	2	batting	91	22	4	.242	—	—	Average (50) — 117 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 91 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Billy Moran	Infielders	16	batting	257	58	1	.226	—	—	Average (45) — 208 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 257 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Vic Power	Infielders	10	No stat row	—	—	—	—	—	—	No rating The source has no batting stat row for this player. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Larry Raines	Infielders	16	batting	9	0	0	.000	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Mickey Vernon	Infielders	8	batting	355	104	8	.293	—	—	Average (56) — 37 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 355 at-bats and 8 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Preston Ward	Infielders	36	batting	148	50	4	.338	—	—	Average (59) — 26 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 148 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Vic Wertz	Infielders	23	batting	43	12	3	.279	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Rocky Colavito	Outfielders	6	both	489	148	41	.303	—	0.00	Strong (64) — 8 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 489 at-bats and 41 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Larry Doby	Outfielders	14	batting	247	70	13	.285	—	—	Average (56) — 37 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 247 at-bats and 13 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Gary Geiger	Outfielders	31	both	195	45	1	.231	—	9.00	Average (46) — 191 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 195 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Rod Graber	Outfielders	29	batting	8	1	0	.125	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Carroll Hardy	Outfielders	30	batting	49	10	1	.204	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Woodie Held	Outfielders	3	batting	144	28	3	.194	—	—	Below average (43) — 229 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 144 at-bats and 3 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Roger Maris	Outfielders	5	batting	182	41	9	.225	—	—	Average (48) — 158 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 182 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Minnie Miñoso	Outfielders	9	batting	556	168	24	.302	—	—	Strong (60) — 20 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 556 at-bats and 24 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Hal Naragon	Outfielders	18	batting	9	3	0	.333	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.

Build a lineup

Exhibition rules use nine hitters, including a DH, and one pitcher. The numbered slots are the batting order. Pick each player once. Opponent: 1958 Baltimore Orioles. Players without a rating remain selectable with estimated performance.

Game to edit

1. C2. 1B3. 2B4. 3B5. SS6. LF7. CF8. RF9. DH

Pitcher Game seed

Keep the seed to replay the same game; change it to play a different exhibition.

Restore a lineup file

Simulated exhibition

Choose a lineup to play an exhibition.

Batting lines

Game log for the selected game

Roster and statistics adapted from Wikipedia contributors, 1958 Cleveland Indians season. Retrieved 2026-09-30T12:47:52.284431+00:00. Source material is under CC BY-SA 4.0. We grouped roster entries, excluded staff, joined stats by Wikipedia page title, converted baseball innings notation to outs, and derived approximate ratings and simulated outcomes. No official affiliation.