1904 New York Giants

Franchise seasons · 1900s seasons

Independent, unofficial historical lineup simulator. Games here are simulated exhibitions, not historical results.

Roster and season statistics

Only players appear here. Staff are excluded from lineup choices. — means the source has no usable value. A roster player may have no batting or pitching row if they did not appear in those tables.

Player	Position group	No.	Stat rows	AB	H	HR	AVG	IP	ERA	Rating
Red Ames	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	115.00	2.27	Average (54) — 34 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 2.27 over 115.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Claude Elliott	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	15.00	3.00	Not enough data The available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Christy Mathewson	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	367.67	2.03	Average (58) — 6 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 2.03 over 367.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Joe McGinnity	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	408.00	1.61	Strong (61) — 1 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 1.61 over 408.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Billy Milligan	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	25.00	5.40	Average (45) — 82 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 5.40 over 25.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dummy Taylor	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	296.33	2.34	Average (55) — 25 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 2.34 over 296.33 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Hooks Wiltse	Pitchers	—	pitching	—	—	—	—	164.67	2.84	Average (51) — 54 of 93 pitchers in the available 1904 rosters An earned-run average of 2.84 over 164.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Frank Bowerman	Catchers	—	both	289	67	2	.232	—	9.00	Average (49) — 95 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 289 at-bats and 2 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Doc Marshall	Catchers	—	batting	17	6	0	.353	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Jim O'Rourke	Catchers	—	batting	4	1	0	.250	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Jack Warner	Catchers	—	batting	287	57	1	.199	—	—	Below average (43) — 155 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 287 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dan Brouthers	Infielders	—	batting	5	0	0	.000	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Bill Dahlen	Infielders	—	batting	523	140	2	.268	—	—	Average (54) — 44 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 523 at-bats and 2 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Art Devlin	Infielders	—	batting	474	133	1	.281	—	—	Average (55) — 38 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 474 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Jack Dunn	Infielders	—	both	181	56	1	.309	—	4.50	Average (58) — 22 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 181 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Billy Gilbert	Infielders	—	batting	478	121	1	.253	—	—	Average (51) — 76 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 478 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Dan McGann	Infielders	—	batting	517	148	6	.286	—	—	Strong (60) — 12 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 517 at-bats and 6 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
John McGraw	Infielders	—	batting	12	4	0	.333	—	—	Not enough data The available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance.
Roger Bresnahan	Outfielders	—	batting	402	114	5	.284	—	—	Average (59) — 18 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 402 at-bats and 5 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
George Browne	Outfielders	—	batting	596	169	4	.284	—	—	Average (58) — 22 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 596 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Mike Donlin	Outfielders	—	batting	132	37	2	.280	—	—	Average (56) — 33 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 132 at-bats and 2 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Moose McCormick	Outfielders	—	batting	203	54	1	.266	—	—	Average (53) — 49 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 203 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.
Sam Mertes	Outfielders	—	batting	532	147	4	.276	—	—	Average (57) — 27 of 174 batters in the available 1904 rosters Batting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 532 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league.

Build a lineup

Exhibition rules use nine hitters, including a DH, and one pitcher. The numbered slots are the batting order. Pick each player once. Opponent: 1904 Boston Americans. Players without a rating remain selectable with estimated performance.

Game to edit

1. C2. 1B3. 2B4. 3B5. SS6. LF7. CF8. RF9. DH

Pitcher Game seed

Keep the seed to replay the same game; change it to play a different exhibition.

Restore a lineup file

Simulated exhibition

Choose a lineup to play an exhibition.

Batting lines

Game log for the selected game

Roster and statistics adapted from Wikipedia contributors, 1904 New York Giants season. Retrieved 2026-09-30T17:06:07.806341+00:00. Source material is under CC BY-SA 4.0. We grouped roster entries, excluded staff, joined stats by Wikipedia page title, converted baseball innings notation to outs, and derived approximate ratings and simulated outcomes. No official affiliation.